Pyrite vs Marcasite

(via Gemmology Queensland, Vol.4, No.7, July 2003)

The marcasites of jewelry are a misnomer, for the brassy colored flattened pyramids and rose cuts, that were hand set or cemented into mid-18th century and Victorian jewelry, were manufactured from pyrite…not marcasite. Marcasite’s lack of chemical stability makes this mineral useless for jewelry purposes.

The word pyrite is derived from the Greek root pyros = fire, thus alluding to the sparks generated when this mineral is struck by steel. The origin of the word marcasite is less certain but is likely derived from the Latin word marcasita.

Although, chemically pyrite and marcasite are dimorphs of the mineral iron sulphide (FeS), their properties are quite different.

Pyrite
Crystal system: cubic
Habit: interpenetrant cubes; modified pyritohedra
Color: brassy yellow
Hardness: 6-6½
Fracture: conchoidal; uneven
Specific gravity: 5
Luster: metallic
Diaphaneity: opaque
Streak: greenish black
Identifying features: brassy with greenish black streak

Marcasite
Crystal system: orthorhombic
Habit: spear-shaped twins; cocks-comb aggregates
Color: brassy yellow
Hardness: 6-6½
Fracture: uneven
Specific gravity: 4.8-4.9
Luster: metallic
Diaphaneity: opaque
Streak: grayish brownish black
Identifying features: evidence of surface degredation (powdering)

Presently marcasite (pyrite) set jewelry is rapidly coming back into vogue as inexpensive surface decoration for jewelry and watches. Most of the newer marcasites are being manufactured in China, and are glued into silver or silver plated copper settings; their cutting and polishing into pointed square shapes must be accurate.

A Tip
When checking marcasite-set jewelry for quality, ensure:
- each marcasite is of uniform size and thickness.
- polished surfaces are free of surface pits.
- the marcasites display a uniform brassy metallic luster in reflected light.